• December 18, 2014

Civil War photograph identity puzzle solved

Print
Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Wednesday, March 26, 2014 4:30 am

WASHINGTON — The 26 Union soldiers were posed for the camera somewhere near Brandy Station, Va., in late 1863 or early 1864.

The front rank stood at parade rest, hands clasped around muskets. The rear ranks stood so their faces could be seen. They were serious young men approaching the final, bloody months of the Civil War.

The Library of Congress, which owns the rare tintype, had described it as an “unidentified company of soldiers” — anonymous Yankees whose stories and fates seemed forgotten.

But last month, a New York high school teacher spotted the photo on a Civil War Facebook page and recognized the image. Now the Library of Congress, which has a digital version on its website, has names and stories to go with the faces.

“Often, the pictures are powerful,” said Helena Zinkham, chief of the library’s prints and photographs division. “But having the biographical narrative so enriches the meaning of the moment.

“Who was just new to the company?” she asked. “Who was just leaving? Who might die later?”

The photograph depicts men of Company H, of the 124th New York infantry, nicknamed “the Orange Blossoms” because many were from Orange County. The outfit had already lost its colonel and many of its men in the war.

“Each individual person had a fate and a story,” Zinkham said.

Two of the men in the photograph would later be killed in combat. Another man would be captured and die in the notorious Andersonville prison camp. And another would live to receive the Medal of Honor and become a member of Congress.

Unusual photo

The picture, an unusual outdoor group photograph, is one of 1,200 Civil War images donated to the library in recent years by collector Tom Liljenquist of McLean, Va.

Liljenquist bought it for $3,500 four years ago at a collectors’ show in Gettysburg, Pa., and gave it to the library in 2010, the library said.

“It’s a magnificent photograph, a very rare half-plate tintype, in its beautiful original folding case,” Liljenquist said Wednesday.

A tintype is a photograph printed on a thin sheet of metal, and “half-plate” refers to the photo’s relatively large size, he said.

When Liljenquist bought it, there was no accompanying identification. He said such cased original photographs, especially outdoor shots, rarely come down through history with detailed information.

“Now it’s just incredible that we have these guys identified,” he said.

Last month, Garry Adelman, vice president of the Center for Civil War Photography, posted a copy of the photo on his Civil War Facebook page to see if anybody had any knowledge about it. “I had no real hope of identifying the thing,” he said.

But when Ryan McIntyre, a high school social studies teacher in Ellenville, N.Y., visited Adelman’s page, he recognized the picture.

“I looked at it and I said, ‘I’ve seen this picture before,’” McIntyre said. He had seen a copy in the holdings of the Historical Society of Walden and the Wallkill Valley in Orange County.

“It was like an ‘Aha!’ moment,” he said.

McIntyre said the copy with the historical society includes a note written in 1910 by Lt. John Hays and identifying many of the men. Hays, who appears in the photo and was in his 20s when it was taken, was probably about 70 in 1910.

McIntyre said the picture and the information about the men also appear in a 2012 history of the regiment by Charles LaRocca, who credits the historical society for the picture and the identities.

Adelman noted: “Having it in a book identified is one thing. Having it (identified) on the Library of Congress catalogue, where everybody can see the (high-resolution) version, is another.”

Doomed men

The men of the company had probably been in the relative comfort of winter quarters, McIntyre said. They appear healthy and well fed, if a little rumpled. “This is not a company that has been on the road,” he added.

They are flanked on the right by their captain, David Crist, who was then about 47. He was killed May 30, 1864, in fighting at Totopotomoy Creek, outside Richmond, Va., according to information gathered by Adelman and McIntyre.

Another officer later described Crist as “a kind friend, a noble soldier, and a man whose whole soul was wrapped up in his country’s cause,” according to an 1870s history of the regiment.

Standing near Crist is British-born Sgt. Thomas Bradley, who many years after the war would be awarded the Medal of Honor for fetching ammunition under heavy fire at the Battle of Chancellorsville in 1863.

Bradley went on to serve as a U.S. congressman for 10 years.

Near him stands James Crist, about 28, who was wounded and captured at Totopotomoy Creek and died Nov. 11, 1864, in the Andersonville prison camp. It’s not clear if or how the Crists were related.

Another doomed soldier in the photograph, standing near James Crist, is Chester Judson, about 18 years old. Judson would be killed by a rebel sniper Sept. 14, 1864, in the trench warfare around Petersburg, Va.

He was shot in the head during the day while at his picket post, but a comrade had to wait until dark to drag his body into Union territory.

“We buried him by moonlight, and it was a most solemn scene,” an officer recounted. “We wrapped him in his blanket, and placed him in a cracker box coffin. A prayer was offered at his grave which was dug and filled in by the chief mourners, and I reported one less man for duty.”

More about

More about

More about

Rules of Conduct

  • 1 Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
  • 2 Don't Threaten or Abuse. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated. AND PLEASE TURN OFF CAPS LOCK.
  • 3 Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
  • 4 Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
  • 5 Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
  • 6 Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.

Welcome to the discussion.

Ft Hood Events

Military Videos